1052: Column 'id' in field list is ambiguous

I have 2 tables. tbl_names and tbl_section which has both the id field in them. How do I go about selecting the id field, because I always get this error:

1052: Column 'id' in field list is ambiguous

Here’s my query:

SELECT id, name, section
  FROM tbl_names, tbl_section 
 WHERE tbl_names.id = tbl_section.id

I could just select all the fields and avoid the error. But that would be a waste in performance. What should I do?

Contents hide

Answers:

Method 1

Why Do These Queries Look Different?

Answers:

Thank you for visiting the Q&A section on Magenaut. Please note that all the answers may not help you solve the issue immediately. So please treat them as advisements. If you found the post helpful (or not), leave a comment & I’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Method 1

SQL supports qualifying a column by prefixing the reference with either the full table name:

SELECT tbl_names.id, tbl_section.id, name, section
  FROM tbl_names
  JOIN tbl_section ON tbl_section.id = tbl_names.id

…or a table alias:

SELECT n.id, s.id, n.name, s.section
  FROM tbl_names n
  JOIN tbl_section s ON s.id = n.id

The table alias is the recommended approach — why type more than you have to?

Why Do These Queries Look Different?

Secondly, my answers use ANSI-92 JOIN syntax (yours is ANSI-89). While they perform the same, ANSI-89 syntax does not support OUTER joins (RIGHT, LEFT, FULL). ANSI-89 syntax should be considered deprecated, there are many on SO who will not vote for ANSI-89 syntax to reinforce that. For more information, see this question.

Method 2

In your SELECT statement you need to preface your id with the table you want to choose it from.

SELECT tbl_names.id, name, section 
FROM tbl_names
INNER JOIN tbl_section 
   ON tbl_names.id = tbl_section.id

SELECT tbl_section.id, name, section 
FROM tbl_names
INNER JOIN tbl_section 
   ON tbl_names.id = tbl_section.id

Method 3

You would do that by providing a fully qualified name, e.g.:

SELECT tbl_names.id as id, name, section FROM tbl_names, tbl_section WHERE tbl_names.id = tbl_section.id

Which would give you the id of tbl_names

Method 4

Already there are lots of answers to your question, You can do it like this also. You can give your table an alias name and use that in the select query like this:

SELECT a.id, b.id, name, section
FROM tbl_names as a 
LEFT JOIN tbl_section as b ON a.id = b.id;

Method 5

The simplest solution is a join with USING instead of ON. That way, the database “knows” that both id columns are actually the same, and won’t nitpick on that:

SELECT id, name, section
  FROM tbl_names
  JOIN tbl_section USING (id)

If id is the only common column name in tbl_names and tbl_section, you can even use a NATURAL JOIN:

SELECT id, name, section
  FROM tbl_names
  NATURAL JOIN tbl_section

Method 6

What you are probably really wanting to do here is use the union operator like this:

(select ID from Logo where AccountID = 1 and Rendered = 'True')
  union
  (select ID from Design where AccountID = 1 and Rendered = 'True')
  order by ID limit 0, 51

Here’s the docs for it https://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.0/en/union.html

Method 7

If the format of the id’s in the two table varies then you want to join them, as such you can select to use an id from one-main table, say if you have table_customes and table_orders, and tha id for orders is like “101“,”102“…”110“, just use one for customers

select customers.id, name, amount, date from customers.orders;

Method 8

SELECT tbl_names.id, tbl_names.name, tbl_names.section
  FROM tbl_names, tbl_section 
 WHERE tbl_names.id = tbl_section.id

All methods was sourced from stackoverflow.com or stackexchange.com, is licensed under cc by-sa 2.5, cc by-sa 3.0 and cc by-sa 4.0

0 0 votes

Article Rating