Generate a random derangement of a list

How can I randomly shuffle a list so that none of the elements remains in its original position?

In other words, given a list A with distinct elements, I’d like to generate a permutation B of it so that

• this permutation is random
• and for each n, a[n] != b[n]

e.g.

a = [1,2,3,4]
b = [4,1,2,3] # good
b = [4,2,1,3] # good

a = [1,2,3,4]
x = [2,4,3,1] # bad

I don’t know the proper term for such a permutation (is it “total”?) thus having a hard time googling. The correct term appears to be “derangement”.

Answers:

Thank you for visiting the Q&A section on Magenaut. Please note that all the answers may not help you solve the issue immediately. So please treat them as advisements. If you found the post helpful (or not), leave a comment & I’ll get back to you as soon as possible.

Method 1

After some research I was able to implement the “early refusal” algorithm as described e.g. in this paper. It goes like this:

import random

def random_derangement(n):
    while True:
        v = [i for i in range(n)]
        for j in range(n - 1, -1, -1):
            p = random.randint(0, j)
            if v[p] == j:
                break
            else:
                v[j], v[p] = v[p], v[j]
        else:
            if v[0] != 0:
                return tuple(v)

The idea is: we keep shuffling the array, once we find that the permutation we’re working on is not valid (v[i]==i), we break and start from scratch.

A quick test shows that this algorithm generates all derangements uniformly:

N = 4

# enumerate all derangements for testing
import itertools
counter = {}
for p in itertools.permutations(range(N)):
    if all(p[i] != i for i in p):
        counter[p] = 0

# make M probes for each derangement
M = 5000
for _ in range(M*len(counter)):
    # generate a random derangement
    p = random_derangement(N)
    # is it really?
    assert p in counter
    # ok, record it
    counter[p] += 1

# the distribution looks uniform
for p, c in sorted(counter.items()):
    print p, c

Results:

(1, 0, 3, 2) 4934
(1, 2, 3, 0) 4952
(1, 3, 0, 2) 4980
(2, 0, 3, 1) 5054
(2, 3, 0, 1) 5032
(2, 3, 1, 0) 5053
(3, 0, 1, 2) 4951
(3, 2, 0, 1) 5048
(3, 2, 1, 0) 4996

I choose this algorithm for simplicity, this presentation briefly outlines other ideas.

Method 2

Such permutations are called derangements. In practice you can just try random permutations until hitting a derangement, their ratio approaches the inverse of ‘e’ as ‘n’ grows.

Method 3

As a possible starting point, the Fisher-Yates shuffle goes like this.

def swap(xs, a, b):
    xs[a], xs[b] = xs[b], xs[a]

def permute(xs):
    for a in xrange(len(xs)):
        b = random.choice(xrange(a, len(xs)))
        swap(xs, a, b)

Perhaps this will do the trick?

def derange(xs):
    for a in xrange(len(xs) - 1):
        b = random.choice(xrange(a + 1, len(xs) - 1))
        swap(xs, a, b)
    swap(len(xs) - 1, random.choice(xrange(n - 1))

Here’s the version described by Vatine:

def derange(xs):
    for a in xrange(1, len(xs)):
        b = random.choice(xrange(0, a))
        swap(xs, a, b)
    return xs

A quick statistical test:

from collections import Counter

def test(n):
    derangements = (tuple(derange(range(n))) for _ in xrange(10000))
    for k,v in Counter(derangements).iteritems():
        print('{}   {}').format(k, v)

test(4):

(1, 3, 0, 2)   1665
(2, 0, 3, 1)   1702
(3, 2, 0, 1)   1636
(1, 2, 3, 0)   1632
(3, 0, 1, 2)   1694
(2, 3, 1, 0)   1671

This does appear uniform over its range, and it has the nice property that each element has an equal chance to appear in each allowed slot.

But unfortunately it doesn’t include all of the derangements. There are 9 derangements of size 4. (The formula and an example for n=4 are given on the Wikipedia article).

Method 4

This should work

import random

totalrandom = False
array = [1, 2, 3, 4]
it = 0
while totalrandom == False:
    it += 1
    shuffledArray = sorted(array, key=lambda k: random.random())
    total = 0
    for i in array:
        if array[i-1] != shuffledArray[i-1]: total += 1
    if total == 4:
        totalrandom = True

    if it > 10*len(array):
        print("'Total random' shuffle impossible")
        exit()
print(shuffledArray)

Note the variable it which exits the code if too many iterations are called. This accounts for arrays such as [1, 1, 1] or [3]

EDIT

Turns out that if you’re using this with large arrays (bigger than 15 or so), it will be CPU intensive. Using a randomly generated 100 element array and upping it to len(array)**3, it takes my Samsung Galaxy S4 a long time to solve.

EDIT 2

After about 1200 seconds (20 minutes), the program ended saying ‘Total Random shuffle impossible’. For large arrays, you need a very large number of permutations… Say len(array)**10 or something.

Code:

import random, time

totalrandom = False
array = []
it = 0

for i in range(1, 100):
    array.append(random.randint(1, 6))

start = time.time()

while totalrandom == False:
    it += 1
    shuffledArray = sorted(array, key=lambda k: random.random())
    total = 0
    for i in array:
        if array[i-1] != shuffledArray[i-1]: total += 1
    if total == 4:
        totalrandom = True

    if it > len(array)**3:
        end = time.time()
        print(end-start)
        print("'Total random' shuffle impossible")
        exit()

end = time.time()
print(end-start)
print(shuffledArray)

Method 5

Here is a smaller one, with pythonic syntax –

import random
def derange(s):
 d=s[:]
 while any([a==b for a,b in zip(d,s)]):random.shuffle(d)
 return d

All it does is shuffles the list until there is no element-wise match. Also, be careful that it’ll run forever if a list that cannot be deranged is passed.It happens when there are duplicates. To remove duplicates simply call the function like this derange(list(set(my_list_to_be_deranged))).

Method 6

import random
a=[1,2,3,4]
c=[]
i=0
while i < len(a):
    while 1:
     k=random.choice(a)
     #print k,a[i]
     if k==a[i]:
         pass
     else:
         if k not in c:
             if i==len(a)-2:
                 if a[len(a)-1] not in c:
                     if k==a[len(a)-1]:
                         c.append(k)
                         break
                 else:
                     c.append(k)
                     break
             else:
                 c.append(k)
                 break
    i=i+1
print c

Method 7

A quick way is to try to shuffle your list until you reach that state. You simply try to shuffle your list until you are left with a list that satisfies your condition.

import random
import copy


def is_derangement(l_original, l_proposal):
    return all([l_original[i] != item for i, item in enumerate(l_proposal)])


l_original = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
l_proposal = copy.copy(l_original)

while not is_derangement(l_original, l_proposal):
    random.shuffle(l_proposal)

print(l_proposal)

All methods was sourced from stackoverflow.com or stackexchange.com, is licensed under cc by-sa 2.5, cc by-sa 3.0 and cc by-sa 4.0