I’m trying to check for a palindrome with Python. The code I have is very for-loop intensive.
And it seems to me the biggest mistake people do when going from C to Python is trying to implement C logic using Python, which makes things run slowly, and it’s just not making the most of the language.
I see on this website. Search for “C-style for”, that Python doesn’t have C-style for loops. Might be outdated, but I interpret it to mean Python has its own methods for this.
I’ve tried looking around, I can’t find much up to date (Python 3) advice for this. How can I solve a palindrome challenge in Python, without using the for loop?
I’ve done this in C in class, but I want to do it in Python, on a personal basis. The problem is from the Euler Project, great site By the way,.
def isPalindrome(n):
lst = [int(n) for n in str(n)]
l=len(lst)
if l==0 || l==1:
return True
elif len(lst)%2==0:
for k in range (l)
#####
else:
while (k<=((l-1)/2)):
if (list[]):
#####
for i in range (999, 100, -1):
for j in range (999,100, -1):
if isPalindrome(i*j):
print(i*j)
break
I’m missing a lot of code here. The five hashes are just reminders for myself.
Concrete questions:
- In C, I would make a for loop comparing index 0 to index max, and then index 0+1 with max-1, until something something. How to best do this in Python?
- My for loop (in in range (999, 100, -1), is this a bad way to do it in Python?
- Does anybody have any good advice, or good websites, or resources for people in my position? I’m not a programmer, I don’t aspire to be one, I just want to learn enough so that when I write my bachelor’s degree thesis (electrical engineering), I don’t have to simultaneously LEARN an applicable programming language while trying to obtain good results in the project. “How to go from basic C to great application of Python”, that sort of thing.
- Any specific bits of code to make a great solution to this problem would also be appreciated, I need to learn good algorithms.. I am envisioning 3 situations. If the value is zero or single digit, if it is of odd length, and if it is of even length. I was planning to write for loops…
PS: The problem is: Find the highest value product of two 3 digit integers that is also a palindrome.
Answers:
Thank you for visiting the Q&A section on Magenaut. Please note that all the answers may not help you solve the issue immediately. So please treat them as advisements. If you found the post helpful (or not), leave a comment & I’ll get back to you as soon as possible.
Method 1
A pythonic way to determine if a given value is a palindrome:
str(n) == str(n)[::-1]
Explanation:
- We’re checking if the string representation of
nequals the inverted string representation ofn - The
[::-1]slice takes care of inverting the string - After that, we compare for equality using
==
Method 2
An alternative to the rather unintuitive [::-1] syntax is this:
>>> test = "abcba" >>> test == ''.join(reversed(test)) True
The reversed function returns a reversed sequence of the characters in test.
''.join() joins those characters together again with nothing in between.
Method 3
Just for the record, and for the ones looking for a more algorithmic way to validate if a given string is palindrome, two ways to achieve the same (using while and for loops):
def is_palindrome(word):
letters = list(word)
is_palindrome = True
i = 0
while len(letters) > 0 and is_palindrome:
if letters[0] != letters[(len(letters) - 1)]:
is_palindrome = False
else:
letters.pop(0)
if len(letters) > 0:
letters.pop((len(letters) - 1))
return is_palindrome
And….the second one:
def is_palindrome(word):
letters = list(word)
is_palindrome = True
for letter in letters:
if letter == letters[-1]:
letters.pop(-1)
else:
is_palindrome = False
break
return is_palindrome
Method 4
The awesome part of python is the things you can do with it. You don’t have to use indexes for strings.
The following will work (using slices)
def palindrome(n):
return n == n[::-1]
What it does is simply reverses n, and checks if they are equal. n[::-1] reverses n (the -1 means to decrement)
“2) My for loop (in in range (999, 100, -1), is this a bad way to do it in Python?”
Regarding the above, you want to use xrange instead of range (because range will create an actual list, while xrange is a fast generator)
My opinions on question 3
I learned C before Python, and I just read the docs, and played around with it using the console. (and by doing Project Euler problems as well 🙂
Method 5
Below the code will print 0 if it is Palindrome else it will print -1
Optimized Code
word = "nepalapen" is_palindrome = word.find(word[::-1]) print is_palindrome
Output:
0
word = "nepalapend" is_palindrome = word.find(word[::-1]) print is_palindrome
Output:
-1
Explaination:
when searching the string the value that is returned is the value of the location that the string starts at.
So when you do word.find(word[::-1]) it finds nepalapen at location 0 and [::-1] reverses nepalapen and it still is nepalapen at location 0 so 0 is returned.
Now when we search for nepalapend and then reverse nepalapend to dnepalapen it renders a FALSE statement nepalapend was reversed to dnepalapen causing the search to fail to find nepalapend resulting in a value of -1 which indicates string not found.
Another method print true if palindrome else print false
word = "nepalapen" print(word[::-1]==word[::1])
output:
TRUE
Method 6
There is also a functional way:
def is_palindrome(word): if len(word) == 1: return True if word[0] != word[-1]: return False return is_palindrome(word[1:-1])
Method 7
I know that this question was answered a while ago and i appologize for the intrusion. However,I was working on a way of doing this in python as well and i just thought that i would share the way that i did it in is as follows,
word = 'aibohphobia'
word_rev = reversed(word)
def is_palindrome(word):
if list(word) == list(word_rev):
print'True, it is a palindrome'
else:
print'False, this is''t a plindrome'
is_palindrome(word)
Method 8
There is much easier way I just found. It’s only 1 line.
is_palindrome = word.find(word[::-1])
Method 9
The most pythonic way to do this is indeed using the slicing notation to reverse the string as mentioned already:
def is_palindrome(string: str) -> bool:
return string == string[::-1]
In some other occasions though (like technical interviews), you may have to write a “proper” algorithm to find the palindrome. In this case, the following should do the trick:
def is_palindrome(string: str) -> bool:
start = 0
end = len(string) - 1
while end >= start:
if string[end] != string[start]:
return False
start += 1
end -= 1
return True
- Set pointers to the start and end of the string
- Iterate while
endexceedsstart - If the character in
endandstartindices don’t match then this is not a palindrome, otherwise keep comparing - Increase
startpointer by 1 - Decrease
endpointer by 1
Test Cases:
import unittest
class Test(unittest.TestCase):
palindromes = ['a', 'aa', 'aba', '12321']
non_palindromes = ['ab', 'aab', 'cacacc']
def test_is_palindrome(self):
for case in self.palindromes:
self.assertTrue(is_palindrome(case))
for case in self.non_palindromes:
self.assertFalse(is_palindrome(case))
if __name__ == '__main__':
unittest.main()
Method 10
You could use this one-liner that returns a bool value:
str(x)==str(x)[::-1]
This works both for words and numbers thanks to the type casting…
Method 11
Here a case insensitive function since all those solutions above are case sensitive.
def Palindrome(string): return (string.upper() == string.upper()[::-1])
This function will return a boolean value.
Method 12
doing the Watterloo course for python, the same questions is raised as a “Lesseon” find the info here:
http://cscircles.cemc.uwaterloo.ca/13-lists/
being a novice i solved the problem the following way:
def isPalindrome(S):
pali = True
for i in range (0, len(S) // 2):
if S[i] == S[(i * -1) - 1] and pali is True:
pali = True
else:
pali = False
print(pali)
return pali
The function is called isPalindrome(S) and requires a string “S”.
The return value is by default TRUE, to have the initial check on the first if statement.
After that, the for loop runs half the string length to check if the character from string “S” at the position “i” is the same at from the front and from the back.
If once this is not the case, the function stops, prints out FALSE and returns false.
Cheers.kg
Method 13
If the string has an uppercase or non-alphabetic character then the function converts all characters to lowercase and removes all non-alphabetic characters using regex finally it applies palindrome check recursively:
import re
rules = [
lambda s: any(x.isupper() for x in s),
lambda s: not s.isalpha()
]
def is_palindrome(s):
if any(rule(s) for rule in rules):
s = re.sub(r'[^w]', '', s).lower()
if len(s) < 2:
return True
if s[0] != s[-1]:
return False
return is_palindrome(s[1:-1])
string = 'Are we not drawn onward, we few, drawn onward to new era?'
print(is_palindrome(string))
the output is True for the input above.
Method 14
maybe you can try this one:
list=input('enter a string:')
if (list==list[::-1]):
print ("It is a palindrome")
else:
print("it is not palindrome")
Method 15
You are asking palindrome in python. palindrome can be performed on strings, numbers and lists. However, I just posted a simple code to check palindrome of a string.
# Palindrome of string
str=raw_input("Enter the stringn")
ln=len(str)
for i in range(ln/2) :
if(str[ln-i-1]!=str[i]):
break
if(i==(ln/2)-1):
print "Palindrome"
else:
print "Not Palindrome"
Method 16
The real easy way to do that it is
word = str(raw_input(""))
is_palindrome = word.find(word[::-1])
if is_palindrome == 0:
print True
else:
print False
And if/else here just for fancy looks. The question about palindrome was on Amazon’s interview for QA
Method 17
Assuming a string ‘s’
palin = lambda s: s[:(len(s)/2 + (0 if len(s)%2==0 else 1)):1] == s[:len(s)/2-1:-1]
# Test
palin('654456') # True
palin('malma') # False
palin('ab1ba') # True
Method 18
word = "<insert palindrome/string>" reverse = word[::-1] is_palindrome = word.find(reverse) print is_palindrome
This was a question in Udacity comp 101, chapter 1. Gives a 0 for palindrome gives a -1 for not. Its simple, and does not use loops.
Method 19
I wrote this code:
word = input("enter: ")
word = ''.join(word.split())`
for x in range(len(word)):
if list(word)[x] == ((list(word)[len(word)-x-1])):
if x+1 == len(word):
print("its pali")
and it works.
it gets the word, then removes the spaces and turns it into a list
then it tests if the first letter is equal to the last and if the 2nd is equal to 2nd last and so on.
then the ‘if x+1 == len(word)’ means that since x starts at 0 it becomes 1 and then for every next .. blah blah blah it works so it works.
Method 20
#compare 1st half with reversed second half # i.e. 'abba' -> 'ab' == 'ba'[::-1] def is_palindrome( s ): return True if len( s ) < 2 else s[ :len( s ) // 2 ] == s[ -( len( s ) // 2 ):][::-1]
Method 21
You can use Deques in python to check palindrome
def palindrome(a_string):
ch_dequeu = Deque()
for ch in a_string:
ch_dequeu.add_rear(ch)
still_ok = True
while ch_dequeu.size() > 1 and still_ok:
first = ch_dequeu.remove_front()
last = ch_dequeu.remove_rear()
if first != last:
still_ok = False
return still_ok
class Deque:
def __init__(self):
self.items = []
def is_empty(self):
return self.items == []
def add_rear(self, item):
self.items.insert(0, item)
def add_front(self, item):
self.items.append(item)
def size(self):
return len(self.items)
def remove_front(self):
return self.items.pop()
def remove_rear(self):
return self.items.pop(0)
Method 22
import string
word = input('Please select a word to test n')
word = word.lower()
num = len(word)
x = round((len(word)-1)/2)
#defines first half of string
first = word[:x]
#reverse second half of string
def reverse_odd(text):
lst = []
count = 1
for i in range(x+1, len(text)):
lst.append(text[len(text)-count])
count += 1
lst = ''.join(lst)
return lst
#reverse second half of string
def reverse_even(text):
lst = []
count = 1
for i in range(x, len(text)):
lst.append(text[len(text)-count])
count += 1
lst = ''.join(lst)
return lst
if reverse_odd(word) == first or reverse_even(word) == first:
print(string.capwords(word), 'is a palindrome')
else:
print(string.capwords(word), 'is not a palindrome')
Method 23
the “algorithmic” way:
import math
def isPalindrome(inputString):
if inputString == None:
return False
strLength = len(inputString)
for i in range(math.floor(strLength)):
if inputString[i] != inputString[strLength - 1 - i]:
return False
return True
Method 24
There is another way by using functions, if you don’t want to use reverse
#!/usr/bin/python
A = 'kayak'
def palin(A):
i = 0
while (i<=(A.__len__()-1)):
if (A[A.__len__()-i-1] == A[i]):
i +=1
else:
return False
if palin(A) == False:
print("Not a Palindrome")
else :
print ("Palindrome")
Method 25
It looks prettier with recursion!
def isPalindrome(x):
z = numToList(x)
length = math.floor(len(z) / 2)
if length < 2:
if z[0] == z[-1]:
return True
else:
return False
else:
if z[0] == z[-1]:
del z[0]
del z[-1]
return isPalindrome(z)
else:
return False
Method 26
def is_palindrome(string): return string == ''.join([letter for letter in reversed(string)])
Method 27
print ["Not a palindrome","Is a palindrome"][s == ''.join([s[len(s)-i-1] for i in range(len(s))])]
This is the typical way of writing single line code
Method 28
def pali(str1):
l=list(str1)
l1=l[::-1]
if l1==l:
print("yess")
else:
print("noo")
str1="abc"
a=pali(str1)
print(a)
Method 29
I tried using this:
def palindrome_numer(num):
num_str = str(num)
str_list = list(num_str)
if str_list[0] == str_list[-1]:
return True
return False
and it worked for a number but I don’t know if a string
Method 30
def isPalin(checkWord):
Hsize = len(lst)/2
seed = 1
palind=True
while seed<Hsize+1:
#print seed,lst[seed-1], lst [-(seed)]
if(lst[seed-1] != lst [-seed]):
palind = False
break
seed = seed+1
return palind
lst = 'testset'
print lst, isPalin(lst)
lst = 'testsest'
print lst, isPalin(lst)
Output
testset True testsest False
All methods was sourced from stackoverflow.com or stackexchange.com, is licensed under cc by-sa 2.5, cc by-sa 3.0 and cc by-sa 4.0